When Victorian Premier Ben Carroll declared himself “a pro-business, financially responsible premier” during an evening's televised leaders' forum, the reaction came swiftly.
His three political rivals openly scoffed. Audible groans came from the audience of 100 undecided voters.
The exchange, during the 17 November News24 and Herald Sun People's Forum at Melbourne's Sofitel hotel, captured the central contradiction confronting Victoria's Labour Government after 12 years in office.
Carroll had been challenged over the Business Council's assessment of Victoria as Australia's most difficult state in which to conduct business. He responded by invoking his family business upbringing, Victoria's medical research credentials, its start-up ecosystem and its internationally recognized major events.
These are genuine economic strengths. Yet they sit uncomfortably alongside the state's taxation burden, deteriorating public infrastructure and increasingly strained finances.
Opposition Leader Jess Wilson argued that small business owners were struggling to pay themselves while meeting employee obligations. Carroll's attempts to distance his leadership from the Daniel Andrews era as well produced an awkward moment when Wilson joked that the former premier was “not Voldemort”.
The forum audience delivered its own verdict. Wilson was selected as the strongest performer by 39 per cent, followed by Greens leader Ellen Sandell on 25 per cent and One Nation's Warren Pickering on 16 per cent. Carroll received just 7 per cent, with 13 per cent undecided.
The result was not a representative statewide poll. Nevertheless, it illustrated the difficulty Carroll faces in persuading voters that a change of premier represents a real change in government.
These are genuine economic strengths. Yet they sit uncomfortably alongside the state's taxation burden, deteriorating public infrastructure and increasingly strained finances.
The polls tell a confronting story.
The latest November polling presents a remarkably consistent picture of Labour's diminished electoral standing.
November 2026 primary vote polling
| Pollster | Coalition | Labor | One Nation | Greens |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lighthouse | 32% | 21% | 23% | 14% |
| RedBridge/Accent | 31% | 23% | 22% | 15% |
| DemosAU | 33% | 18% | 21% | 17% |
| Resolve | 30% | 22% | 23% | 13% |
The RedBridge/Accent survey reported a Coalition two-party-preferred lead of 57 to 43 per cent, while DemosAU reported 56 to 44 per cent.
An independent polling aggregation updated on 13 November estimated Coalition support at 54.5 per cent two-party-preferred, against Labor's 45.5 per cent.
Perhaps the most remarkable development is One Nation's support, polling around 22 per cent and challenging Labor's primary vote. The combined vote of the traditional major parties has fallen to historically unusual levels.
The October preferred-premier poll was equally revealing: Wilson led Carroll by 48 to 34 per cent, with 18 per cent undecided.
ABC election analysis published on 18 November identifies substantial uncertainty surrounding preference flows, particularly in outer-suburban and regional electorates. Statewide polling cannot be translated mechanically into parliamentary seats.
The Big Build: An infrastructure integrity crisis
The Royal Commission into the Integrity of Major Public and Civil Infrastructure Construction Projects has exposed disturbing evidence concerning the administration of taxpayer-funded construction.
Established in August, the inquiry is examining alleged corruption, criminal conduct and serious misconduct across major Victorian projects.

Evidence presented this week included text messages suggesting CFMEU officials pressured contractors to employ a member of the Bandidos motorcycle gang on a government construction site.
The commission also examined timesheets that appeared inconsistent with telephone-location records, eliciting questions about whether public projects were charged for hours not worked.
Further evidence reported on 18 November concerned a $165,000 payment to a motorcycle gang member for work a labour-hire company director acknowledged had not been performed. The inquiry also heard about substantial consulting payments to a senior union official and alleged inflation of catering invoices.
These are allegations and evidence under examination, not final findings of criminal guilt.
Nevertheless, they raise fundamental questions about procurement oversight, competitive contracting and the capacity of public authorities to protect taxpayers' interests.
The commission's final report is not due until 2027. Whatever its eventual findings, the business community has a legitimate interest in understanding how such practices could allegedly occur within major public construction projects.
Record debt and the cost of the Big Build
Victoria's financial position adds another dimension to the debate.
The state is carrying an exceptionally large debt burden, with projections extending towards $200 billion in coming years, depending on the debt measure and reporting period.
Borrowing to finance productive infrastructure is not inherently irresponsible. But governments must demonstrate that projects generate sufficient economic and social returns to justify their costs.
Victoria's experience has been complicated by substantial construction overruns.
North East Link's estimated cost has risen from $15.8 billion to approximately $26.1 billion. The West Gate Tunnel and Metro Tunnel have also experienced significant escalation.
The Suburban Rail Loop is still a particularly contentious long-term commitment, given its enormous projected construction and operating costs.
The issue is not whether Victoria needs better transport infrastructure. It unquestionably does.
The issue is whether successive governments have applied sufficiently rigorous cost-benefit analysis, procurement discipline and fiscal oversight before committing taxpayers to expenditure spanning generations.
The issue is not whether Victoria needs better transport infrastructure. It unquestionably does.
The roads are falling apart.
While billions are committed to major transport projects, Victoria's existing roads have become an increasingly visible source of public frustration.
Figures cited in the accompanying research indicate that 48 per cent of the state's approximately 23,000-kilometre road network was classified as poor or very poor in 2024, compared with 39 per cent in 2021.
Potholes and deteriorating road surfaces impose tangible costs on motorists, freight operators, agricultural businesses and regional communities.
The underlying problem goes beyond individual potholes. Deferred preventative maintenance allows relatively inexpensive repairs to become far more substantial reconstruction liabilities.
The government has allocated additional funding for road repairs, but the question remains whether maintenance budgets are adequate to arrest deterioration across the network.
For businesses dependent on efficient freight and transport connections, road quality is an economic issue, not simply a matter of driver convenience.
Victoria's punishing property tax burden.
Perhaps the clearest commercial grievance concerns property taxation.
Victoria's property tax structure imposes substantial acquisition and holding costs on developers, investors and landlords.
For a standard $1 million property transaction, stamp duty is approximately $55,000 in Victoria, compared with roughly $39,400 in New South Wales and $38,000 for a Queensland investment property.
The contrast in land tax thresholds is equally significant.
Victoria's COVID Debt Repayment Plan lowered the general land tax threshold to $50,000, compared with thresholds of approximately $1.075 million in New South Wales and $600,000 in Queensland for eligible individual landholders.
These are taxable land values, not total property prices, and exemptions and ownership structures affect the comparison.
The Victorian regime also includes additional taxes and surcharges.
Foreign purchasers of applicable residential property face an additional 8 per cent duty. Eligible absentee owners face a 4 per cent annual surcharge, while the Vacant Residential Land Tax and Windfall Gains Tax create further potential liabilities.
For investors, the cumulative effect can materially reduce yields and alter project feasibility.
These taxes also operate alongside construction costs, financing expenses and development contributions.
Governments require revenue to provide services. But there is a legitimate economic debate about whether Victoria's dependence on property taxation is discouraging precisely the investment needed to expand housing supply.
For investors, the cumulative effect can materially reduce yields and alter project feasibility.
Payroll tax and the friction of red tape
Property taxation is only one part of the business cost equation.
Payroll tax increases employment costs for businesses above the applicable thresholds, while Victoria's COVID-era payroll surcharge arrangements add further liabilities for larger employers.

Industry organisations have also criticised the complexity of planning approvals, building permits and meeting regulatory requirements.
The Australian Institute of Building Surveyors has highlighted duplicated documentation between councils and state authorities. Housing industry bodies have questioned the costs associated with new construction standards and extended approval processes.

For developers, every additional month awaiting approval increases financing and holding costs. For small builders, administrative requirements divert resources from construction and employment.
Victoria's housing ambitions therefore confront a practical contradiction: governments want private industry to deliver more homes while industry argues that the tax and regulatory framework makes development increasingly difficult.
The expensive legacy of political decisions
The record goes beyond infrastructure and taxation.
Victoria's COVID response involved exceptionally prolonged lockdowns, with serious consequences for hospitality, retail, tourism and small business.
The first hotel quarantine failures contributed to the state's devastating second wave, since prolonged restrictions created lasting economic and social disruption.
The government defended its public health measures as necessary to protect lives. Their proportionality, implementation and economic consequences remain legitimate subjects of scrutiny.
After that came the cancellation of the 2026 Commonwealth Games.
The Victorian Auditor-General found that abandoning the event cost taxpayers more than $589 million, following substantial shortcomings in the first cost estimates and planning processes.
The earlier cancellation of the East West Link contract in 2015 also resulted in substantial termination costs exceeding a billion dollars without delivering the proposed road.
These decisions arose in different circumstances and cannot simply be aggregated as equivalent failures. They nevertheless demonstrate the financial consequences that can follow inadequate planning, changing political priorities and major contractual commitments.
What a political reset would require
Victoria retains solid economic strengths: leading universities, sophisticated professional services, advanced medical research, an established construction industry and internationally connected businesses.
Labor can point toward significant public transport investments and improvements in infrastructure capacity. Its supporters also argue that borrowing and taxation have helped underwrite essential services and long-term economic development.
The competing concern is whether the current fiscal and regulatory settings remain sustainable.
For any government taking office after 28 November, the pragmatic challenges will be substantial: stabilising debt, improving procurement transparency, maintaining existing infrastructure, decreasing unnecessary regulatory delays and establishing a credible taxation framework.
None can be resolved by changing the occupant of the Premier's office alone.
None can be resolved by changing the occupant of the Premier's office alone.
Carroll's declaration that he is pro-business deserves to be assessed against quantitative outcomes rather than political rhetoric.
Those outcomes include investment confidence, housing feasibility, employment costs, infrastructure condition and the responsible management of public finances.
The election will determine which political leadership Victorians entrust with addressing those challenges.
The deeper test will come afterwards: whether Victoria can reconcile its overly ambitious public investment agenda with the financial discipline and competitive business environment necessary to sustain it.